I tried this side by side with Noir Extreme EDP, NOT the parfum.
When I put them both on the original was definitely sweeter and smoother, the dupe was more scratchy and watery. My wife just smelt the same thing on both hands and they certainly had a very strong resemblance.
The big difference was in the far dry-down, when I got home from work the dupe felt like it was just about gone but the original had a deep-sweet-comforting scent still lingering on my hand, which I really liked.
So, although they were different I feel the scents, in the air, would be very similar making the dupe great value for a similar experience. That said I would 100% get the original if this scent was a love more than a like, just for that deep-warm dry-down.
I will order Intense Black For Men - 1260 next time and re-test.
Scent - 5 / 5
Performance - 4 / 5
I wanted to base my reviews on more than just an unmeasured opinion, so I have used this method to rate all of my purchases at week 1 (under 7 days after delivery) and after week 4 (generally mentioned ‘maceration’ time). I always spray 2x each side in the clavicle, 1x behind each ear and the back of my neck, never on clothes.
With a total score of 10 equally split between smell and performance.
Smell: 0-5
This is obviously just my own taste
Performance: 0-5
Checked at 1, 2, 3, 5 & 9 hrs)
I can certainly say that, without exception, every scent has improved in performance between weeks 1 & 4 and by week 12 many have developed further with tobacco and other warm notes becoming much richer.
I hope this is helpful
DK
Check out Mags Frags review which he calls a 10/10