Erwin For Men - 0552

Too much citric/lemon on it. Erolfa is more sophisticated with floral and a bit more spicy.

Bought 13 15ml extraits . Defo Hits Blonde amber, bromptons immortal, masculine pluriel, mefisto , deified , widian London, torino 22 , erolfa . However some not very good , not sure if need to macerate but the following had a plastic smell to them and were very weak , couldn't pick out any notes ,just smelt poor . Purpose 50 , ormande jayne man , ormande jayne motabaco. To put into more context I now own 24 15ml extraits to which 3 are absolutely terrible at present, hope maceration improves them , 21 are good to brilliant, it's hard to criticise with these numbers . Hopefully P.P can communicate why 3 are so bad ! Will still be ordering more in future .

Great freshie performance 3 or 4 hours

Very Good

Billiant

This is a gentleman, classic fresh fragrance. The dry down is beautiful. So glad to try it (never smelled the original).
I have the 6ml oil. Will order a bigger bottle soon.

Very close to the original, but the extrait doesn't last a long time before fading, probably about 3 hours on my skin. I know the original didn't last long either, but I've noticed some PP creations mostly last far longer than the originals, pity this one doesn't, but still worth it.

This is clean, pleasant, but powerful for a freshie.

It could easily pass for a scent of someone on a boat in the Mediterranean!

It's so nice and got a little bit of everything

Option Review:30ml Spray Extract
You must get this in extract. Erolfa has been a love of mine for many years. The opening is one of the best citrus' that has ever existed. But it is gone so soon. Not anymore. With PP's extract you get it for hours. This is a masterpiece, that The House of Creed could only dream of. It is frankly just like Erolfa, only denser, stronger and just damn better! I have flacons of Erolfa that take years to get close to this power. This is a PERFECT example of the power and beauty of the extrait. Now I have an Erolfa I can be proud of.

Unremarkable.

I have not smelled the original, but this made me want to re-evaluate what I think of as a 10 in fragrances. It is GREAT. It is clean, utterly inoffensive, and just fully developed with no tinge of cheap like so many male fragrances have. Damn well done.

Stunning fragrance!..Fresh; fruity and salty.....Reminds me of sailing on a boat on the Mediterranean with the fresh salty air hitting my skin, and the wonderful smell of fresh fruit wafting from the orchards.

This one is hidden gem. It reminds me a lot on Creed MI

Just like the original, but it lasts and projects more. A beautiful, fresh, complex, intriguing, great fragrance

Musc / citrus frag - good quality

Musky when first applied but dries down well.another great smell

Smells quite strong and musky when first applied but after a while it smells nice! Good quality and long lasting

very good & very long lasting! perfect for everyday use

Classy scent, cant really go wrong with this - very true to the Original.

An old school barbershop scent that lasts well.