I smelt the original at the TF store and though it was an archetypal TF private line smoky scent. It was like someone had taken the spices out of Ebene Fume and just left the darkness and the smoke, I loved it! I ordered PP's extract the minute it was available.
When I first smelt it it felt the scent was peppery where the original had been more smoky. I re-smelt the original recently and it confirmed my first impression had been bang on. The scents are certainly in the same space but the original just has that Givaudan captive magic that PP aren't meant to be able to replicate and, in all fairness, they can't. The smoke here is replaced with a peppery-ness that fills the space but doesn't quite get you all the way.
PPs version is very nice on it own and had my friend asking me what I was wearing because he liked it so much. If you think you're paying £8 for a perfect copy of scents like this, you need to think again. This rendition is fantastic value and will still have you smelling great. Just ask my friend.
Scent - 4 / 5
Performance - 4 / 5
I wanted to base my reviews on more than just an unmeasured opinion, so I have used this method to rate all of my purchases at week 1 (under 7 days after delivery) and after week 4 (generally mentioned ‘maceration’ time). I always spray 2x each side in the clavicle, 1x behind each ear and the back of my neck, never on clothes.
With a total score of 10 equally split between smell and performance.
Smell: 0-5
This is obviously just my own taste
Performance: 0-5
Checked at 1, 2, 3, 5 & 9 hrs)
I can certainly say that, without exception, every scent has improved in performance between weeks 1 & 4 and by week 12 many have developed further with tobacco and other warm notes becoming much richer.
I hope this is helpful
DK